Why Design Thinking is better than traditional approach?

Article written by: Mashhood Alam

TRADITIONAL APPROACH

In traditional approach, for evaluating any business proposition, the two most important aspects that are taken into account by business executives are (1) Viability, and (2) Feasibility. This approach looks at the business benefits of a proposal (viability) and then evaluate whether it is doable in a practical manner (with through own resources or partnering with some) in a timely fashion or not (feasibility). The initiative which ranks the highest on these two metrics, is blessed with funding and kicked off. It seems like a very reasonable way of solving problems. Then why do more than 95 % of these initiatives do not live up to their expectations? There are several reasons:

  1. Both viability and feasibility projections are based on assumptions about the future.
  2. The approach follows waterfall methodology to plan for a long time, implement for even longer time and then shove the solution down stakeholders’ throats.
  3. Is usually compartmentalized and uses silo-ed thinking.
  4. Takes months or even years before key stakeholders see a solution.
  5. Is focused on “How” and “What”.

THE NEW DESIGN THINKING APPROACH

Design Thinking is a human-centered design approach that starts with understanding the needs of the stakeholders (desirability) and bringing the viability and feasibility aspects together.

Here are the key tenets of Design Thinking:

1) Empathy

At the heart of Design Thinking is an empathetic understanding of the user / stakeholder. Trying to have intent observations with a childish curiosity, not just paying attention to what the stakeholder says, but paying attention to actions actively listening to what wasn’t expressed to have insights into the thoughts and feelings. It is easier said than done though.

2) Explore the problem space before thinking about the solution

Contrary to the traditional approach where the proposition starts with a solution in mind, Design Thinking is based on exploring the problem space first, before even thinking about a solution. Using divergent thinking first to explore all the different perspectives about the stakeholders and their context, bring a common understanding of stakeholder and define the problem that needs to be solved using convergent thinking.

This helps in answering the “Why” of the initiative before thinking about “How” and “What”.

3) Collaboration with diverse perspectives to ideate

Design Thinking is based on the power of diverse perspectives. Bringing key stakeholders from different lines of businesses, expertise, experience levels and backgrounds together in one room and facilitating an environment where judgments are deferred to bring as many ideas out as possible. This again highlights the importance of diversity of ideas for ideation before using convergent thinking to select the best ideas for possible solutions.

4) Prototype not plan

Another key aspect of Design Thinking is its bias towards action. Instead of talking about the concept to death, building a prototype is required. A prototype could be as simple as a sketch on a piece of paper or as complex as a mockup using design tools on a computer. The whole idea is that as you prototype, you see how the solution might actually be used in real life. It also reduces the need to invest tremendous resources to get user feedback.

5) Get feedback from key stakeholders at each stage

They beauty of this approach is to involve the user / key stakeholder throughout the design cycle. Not just obtain feedback from the user on the prototype, but even involving the users in coming up with ideas and prototyping. Show (not tell) how a solution might look like for them and get feedback with an open mind.

At this point, also obtain feedback from business and technology / operational side to ensure the idea is both viable and feasible.

6) Iterate

And finally, be ready to fail and try again. The advantage of this approach is that, you’ll know fairly soon whether your solution direction is on the right direction, unlike the traditional approach where user is the last to have a glimpse at the solution.

Fail early, fail fast.

MINDSETS FOR DESIGN THINKING

Design Thinking is a process that is best practiced with following mindsets (from Stanford d School):

  • Human centered
  • Mindful of process
  • Culture of prototyping
  • Show don’t tell
  • Radical collaboration
  • Bias towards action

Article taken from: http://mashhoodalam.com/2015/07/03/what-is-design-thinking-and-why-is-it-better/

 

Archive